Blueberry Grilled Cheese (With Goat Cheese & Basil)

Take your sandwich game to new heights with this blueberry grilled cheese recipe! Made with fresh berries, goat cheese, and arugula, this is comfort food meets gourmet. It’s sweet, tangy, and perfectly gooey. (Trust me, you’ll be hooked after one bite!)

Not Your Grandma’s Grilled Cheese

Let’s talk grilled cheese. You might be wondering why in the heck we’re calling this one a “grilled cheese” instead of a “panini” or something fancy. Turns out, “panini” is just a cold sandwich in Italy (which I found out during my first ever visit there!), so we’re sticking with good ole grilled cheese for simplicity.

This blueberry grilled cheese recipe is a sophisticated twist on the classic. It’s easy to make, but the combination of fresh blueberries, tangy goat cheese, and peppery arugula totally elevates it!

One bite, and you’ll soon see why this gooey, sweet-and-savory creation is about to become your new go-to. Pair it with a side of blueberry cucumber salad for the ultimate lunch or dinner!

Grab These Ingredients

To make this blueberry grilled cheese, you’ll need 3 main items. (But to truly take it to the next level, you’ll want to include a few extras.)

• Bread: To start, you’ll need 2 thick slices of bread. Bonus points if you use sourdough—the best bread for grilled cheese sandwiches!
• Olive Oil: Next, you’ll need 1 teaspoon of olive oil. Butter or mayo will work, too (it’s up to you!).
• Cheese: For creamy decadence, add 2 tablespoons of goat cheese. Pair that with 2 slices of any mild white cheese, like havarti or mozzarella.
• Blueberries: Next, throw in ¼ cup of freshly chopped blueberries.
• Greens: Add a pop of color by including ¼ cup of fresh arugula (or spinach). I also like to include a few basil leaves for some extra flavor.
• Salt And Pepper: Sprinkle a pinch of salt and pepper for good measure.
• Balsamic: Finally, optionally include a drizzle of balsamic vinegar or balsamic reduction for extra tang and that perfect final touch.

Making This Sandwich Is A Breeze

Don’t you worry—this fancy blueberry grilled cheese is easy peasy. (The most tedious part is halving the blueberries!)

Step 1: Coat The Outside
Spread olive oil (or butter/mayo) onto the outward-facing side of each bread slice.

Step 2: Add The Cheese
Spread the goat cheese evenly on the inside of each piece of bread, then top with an additional slice of havarti or mozzarella.

Step 3: Add The Fillings
Pile the chopped blueberries, arugula, and basil onto one piece of bread. Sprinkle with salt and pepper, optionally adding a drizzle of balsamic. Top the remaining piece of bread with cheese.

Step 4: Cook The Sandwich
Cook your blueberry grilled cheese in a pan or panini press on medium heat for about 5 minutes, flipping halfway with a spatula, until everything is melted and hot.

Flavor Mix-Up

This sandwich is pretty versatile and forgiving in terms of ingredients. You can swap the cheese, fruit, or other items and still have delicious results!

Berry Bliss: Swap out blueberries for raspberries or blackberries. You can even use some no-pectin jam for a more concentrated sweetness. Add a sprinkle of chopped fresh mint or thyme for an extra burst of freshness!

Apple Brie: Replace blueberries with thinly sliced apples and swap goat cheese for creamy Brie cheese. Drizzle honey for a subtly sweet note!

Caramelized Onion: Add a handful of caramelized onions to the blueberries for a mouthwatering sweet and savory blend.

Nutty: Sprinkle some chopped walnuts or pecans over the blueberries for the perfect crunch and nutty flavor.

Load Up On More Sandies

Strawberry Grilled Cheese (With Avocado and Basil)

30 minutes

Pressed Eggplant Sandwiches With Pesto

2 hours 40 minutes

Avocado Veggie Sandwich

15 minutes

Gouda Grilled Cheese With Roasted Veggies

30 minutes